Top 10 Model Train Brands Ranked by Hobbyists
We rank the top 10 model train brands according to hobbyist reviews, quality, and collector appeal.
Which model train brands do experienced hobbyists trust the most? We dug through forums, product reviews, and layout tours to find the names that consistently get top marks for quality, availability, and collector value.
Whether you’re a returning model railroader or evaluating your first serious investment, this list will help you sort the best from the rest.
1. Lionel
Best for: Collectors, O Scale, and Traditional American Trains
Lionel is synonymous with model trains for many Americans. Known for durable O scale engines, postwar nostalgia, and robust collector demand, they’re a top choice for hobbyists looking to combine classic style with modern tech like LionChief remote systems.
If you’re deciding between Lionel and its most accessible competitor, our Lionel vs Bachmann comparison breaks it all down.
2. Bachmann
Best for: Affordable HO and N Scale Sets
Bachmann has become the go-to brand for beginners thanks to its wide availability and competitive pricing. Their HO and N scale sets are easy to find, and their DCC-ready Spectrum line offers solid upgrades for growing layouts.
Many of the best HO scale starter sets include Bachmann equipment for good reason.
3. Kato
Best for: Japanese Precision in N and HO Scale
Kato’s engineering standards are second to none, especially in N scale. Their Unitrack system is known for near-flawless connectivity, and their smooth, quiet motors make them a favorite for city-based or space-saving layouts.
4. MTH (Mike’s Train House)
Best for: O Scale Realism and Digital Control
MTH took the realism of O scale to new heights. Their Proto-Sound 3.0 system introduced synchronized smoke, sound, and lighting control long before other brands caught up. Though MTH scaled down operations, their locomotives are still widely traded and prized.
5. Atlas
Best for: Track Systems and Versatile Locomotives
Atlas is a layout builder’s best friend. Known for highly reliable track systems and dependable locomotives, they’ve been a cornerstone of the HO and N scale worlds for decades. Many serious hobbyists swear by their flex track and turnouts.
6. Athearn
Best for: American Freight Prototypes in HO
Athearn specializes in North American freight models, with road-specific detail that appeals to both collectors and operations-focused hobbyists. Their Genesis line is especially well-regarded for its prototypical accuracy and build quality.
7. Piko
Best for: Budget G Scale and European HO
Piko brings German efficiency to garden railroads and European HO layouts. Their G scale trains are weather-resistant and affordable, making them a strong alternative to more expensive brands in the large-scale category.
8. Märklin
Best for: High-End Collectors and AC Operation
Märklin is a premium brand with a loyal following in Europe and among serious collectors. Their digital control systems and metal construction add heft, realism, and longevity. While their AC system isn’t widely adopted in the U.S., it performs flawlessly once mastered.
9. Walthers
Best for: Structure Kits and HO Scale Ecosystems
While best known as a distributor, Walthers has earned its place on this list with its Cornerstone structure kits and reliable HO locomotives. Their offerings make it easy to build realistic towns, industries, and urban environments.
Shop Walthers Cornerstone Kits
10. LGB (Lehmann Gross Bahn)
Best for: Premium Garden Railways
LGB trains are built to run outdoors year-round. Their rugged G scale locomotives and rolling stock are favorites among garden railroaders and collectors alike. With German design and weatherproofing, they’re a top-tier choice for backyard empires.
Final Thoughts
Each brand on this list brings something different to the table. Whether you’re buying your first set or upgrading to a layout-worthy fleet, starting with trusted manufacturers can help you avoid common pitfalls and wasted money.
To see how these brands compare in terms of product bundles and beginner-friendliness, check out our breakdown of the best model train sets for 2025.
